The Rose-Colored Glasses – Why I’m Not Really That Excited for WoW: Classic

There was another big, huge WoW announcement worth talking about that I have skipped out on so far.

WoW: Classic.

No one expected Blizzard to actually announce this. I certainly didn’t. Sure, while the announcement was more barren than the actual Classic Barrens, it…existed. There was even a pseudo-cinematic and everything!

Here’s the thing – I, frankly, have hated the concept of a Legacy Server for a long time because of the community around it. A lot of the people tend to be inflammatory, particularly once Elysium came forward and went down. Armchair lawyers, people who believe that those that play the current game are suckers or worse, and more in the deepest dregs of YouTube comments.

But, fundamentally, my biggest reason for not being excited for a Classic Server is this: Vanilla WoW just isn’t that fun at this point in time, at least for me.

And here’s the kicker, having led with that statement – I loved Vanilla WoW. I have played since June of 2005, and raided multiple tiers right up until the launch of Burning Crusade. The game design captured me with it’s world, gameplay, and sense of immersion and ability to lose myself in the game.

At the time, yes – World of Warcraft was a revolution and tour de force in MMO design. While games like Everquest had experience penalties upon death, and many games in the genre didn’t make use of instanced content, WoW made huge gambles. It assumed:

-MMO’s have a market cap beyond 500,000 players (the peak for games like EQ) and to reach that potential, mechanical complexity and gameplay punishment had to be reduced.

-All players should have an opportunity to experience the top bosses and content in the game, without waiting through ridiculous outdoor spawn-timers and rampant ganking on the spawn point. (with few exceptions)

-The world is as big a character as any individual person or NPC.

These gambles paid off in spades. WoW reached over 5 million subscribers back then and grew further beyond that point.

However, I do think it is worth saying the obvious point – the game design and mechanics of 2004, with development origins in 1999, don’t hold up in 2017, let alone 2018 or 2019 or whenever the game ends up relaunching. While WoW: Classic was indeed a huge innovator in ease of gameplay, there was still a great amount of grinding – PvP rep farms requiring near-constant gameplay, even basic tier raiding mandated consumable farming for far longer than we have seen, and the leveling grind took months to reach level 60, not due to any large amount of content, but a lot of back and forth flying and boating between zones. Mounts? Good luck. Flying? Nope, and not just not on Argus.

But there is a lot of analysis outside of this blog of those points, and for some types of people – those things are the point.

I think, however, that the biggest argument against Classic is this – the Vanilla experience for many players is the sum of their lives at that point.

For me, Vanilla was an escape from a lackluster real life. I had a shitty job, poor living situation, and at that point in time, Vanilla WoW was my best escape. More so than television or any other game, WoW sucked me in and allowed me to think about better things for just a while. As my situation improved in real life, the game improved with it – new patches of content, and the ability to raid upon reaching the level cap. My journey through original WoW content is tied inextricably to my life journey at that time, and it is a thing I think about constantly. Would I be happy to play Vanilla WoW in my current life-state? No. The game demanded hours upon hours upon hours, an investment I was happy to make when the real-life around me wasn’t that great and I had time to pass in order to stop thinking about it – but today? No way.

But at the same time, I am happy Blizzard is doing it. I might try it. I am certainly happy for the people who want to play it, and for those who never got to see it and want to. I don’t write this to try to dissuade anyone from playing, or certainly to stop people from feeling excited. I do find myself very curious as to what happens if indeed the nostalgia alone cannot propel this effort to the success that those who support it tend to envision. Legacy Servers, even the most popular, often drew large numbers of players solely because they were free. At its peak, Elysium had 150,000 accounts. These were not concurrent logged-in users, but just those who created accounts. When the server community migrated after the Blizzard C&D, their new server effort raised money through a T-shirt campaign, an effort which sold an embarassingly small number of shirts. At the newest home of the Elysium technology, a pair of founding members walked off with the crowdfunded cash for the server, and made out with a whopping sum of cash…just north of $2,000 USD. These things are why I highly doubt the potential success of a legacy server – people can create accounts for free but when the time comes to vote with their wallets, many of these vocal individuals don’t put up the cash to support the effort.

Now, you’d be right to point out that there is the very-real possibility that an official server from Blizzard would have automatic trust, the value of which will increase the number of people willing to pay for such a server. This is a point with which I agree. Further, a lot of this is hypothetical, as we have no indication from Blizzard as to what, if any amount, that Blizzard might charge for the server access, or if it might be a freebie with a current game subscription, or somehow embrace some other business model.

And all of this also depends on a large number of other questions, which we have no answers to. What version of classic WoW do we get? Is it just 1.0? Do we jump right to 1.12? Does it maintain a similar release schedule to simulate the same feeling of watching the game evolve? If so, does the game eventually upgrade to Burning Crusade and then Wrath of the Lich King?

I guess my point in writing this, besides drawing an unnecessary line in the sand is this – as someone who enjoyed WoW at launch but doesn’t think it would hold up in a current gaming world, I wonder how durable the audience for this server is. There is no doubt the demand is there, however, will it hold?

I guess we’ll all find out, once Blizzard pops out their next taste of Vanilla.

7 thoughts on “The Rose-Colored Glasses – Why I’m Not Really That Excited for WoW: Classic

  1. Very interesting article, thank you for sharing.

    I won’t be playing WoW classic either. I have found memories when I started, specially of spending entire nights in the middle of the week playing with my friends, sleeping only an hour or two. (Something unthinkable today xD)

    I look back and am 100% sure that I did all that because I was having fun with my friends, not because the game was better back then.

    The game became more balanced, and evolved the same way our lives evolved. If you work, have family, etc., and dont have time to be walking to the dungeons, you can use the Group Finder tool. But NO ONE stops you from finding your own group and walking there. The same way no one is forced to get a mount at level 20. Or flying at 60. (Speaking of that, I don’t understand how some people complain that they cant fly in Broken Isles or Argus, but then say vanilla was better because you couldn’t fly)

    This next bit of opinion may be controversial, but I assure you I know some cases of people who actually think like this: some people just want to go back to vanilla, because back then, if you had a ton of hours to spend in the game, you could become much stronger than most players. These people just like feeling more powerful and better than others. I know someone who hates the LFR, because and I quote “it allows anyone with gear to raid”. Well….but that’s the point. Why shouldn’t non raiders be able to experience the content of the raids?

    Not everyone can spend 6 hours a day playing WoW 🙂

    But I digress, sorry about that. All this being said, I genuinely feel happy for the players who wanted WoW Classic. I wont be playing it, but I hope its what they wanted all this time 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Good points and conversation! I agree with your “controversial” opinion – I do think that there was a time spent = player power paradigm back then, which Blizzard has worked actively to curtail over the years. I remember when I finally got full epics – about a year into raiding. It was awesome, and it took raiding 6 nights a week, 4 hours at a time to get there! But I think there is a reason we have moved on from that to what I think are (mostly) better looting models – Vanilla only wanted your time, where modern WoW tends to reward you for simply sticking with the game for the long haul, even if your play sessions are short.

      That said, I am very curious to see what comes out of this and how launch works out!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I love how people are calling it Classic Vanilla.
    When it came out, all the cool kids were playing it; some stayed and some ran to chase the next shiny hipster thing. If memory serves, it was before blogging technology (I believe blogs and WotLK lined up) and information was very hard to get on the game. Oh, the nostalgia!
    I think to make this idea work that you’ll be able to transfer your character at 60 to the current WoW – there has to be some goal because, as you’ve said, we’ve all moved on in our lives. I look forward to playing tourist and seeing the sights, even if I have to run, run, run.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Haha, now that Blizzard has branded it Classic it’s this weird quagmire of naming! I guess Vanilla should be the original release, and Classic the new servers? Hmm…

      Oh man, Thott (the guy that made Thottbott) played on my server back then. I liked his site, but it was just a really bright version of WoWhead with minimal comments or non-database content. Then there was Allakhazam, and random fan Xanga’s, LiveJournals, and the like. Memories…

      I am curious to see if Blizzard offers a transfer option. A part of me would like that, a part of me knows that doing so is going to open up banshee shrieking from the Nostalrius remnants. I also find myself wondering if Blizzard will try implementing non-gameplay QoL improvements like the current character models. A part of me thinks that would be really cool, but then would it be authentic? No. It’s a tricky tightrope for them to walk, and I am waiting to see how this shapes up.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.